Gordon stares down at the scarred side of Harvey Dent. But, of course, theres still an argument to be had as to who would have made for the better villain, and which scenario would have left Gotham City better off in the end. COMMISSIONER GORDON: The Joker won. One, hes alone. BEST VALUE in digital Bible study. Rachel enrolled in Harvard law school and got an internship at the Gotham City District Attorney's office during her first year. The Joker has kidnapped both Dent and Rachel and set them both to blow so that Batman can only rescue one ( opportunity cost ). While Holmes' take on the character was divisive, something that led to her being nominated for Worst Supporting Actress at the Golden Raspberry Awards, Nolan wasn't swayed by public opinion. rev2023.1.18.43174. In this movie, Rachel is not only involved in Bruce's life but in Harvey Dent's life as well. Rachel is intrigued by the masked crime-fighter, unaware that he is her old friend Bruce. A dark knight." - James Gordon. He wanted Holmes back, but it was scheduling conflicts that kept her away. Looking at the chain of events that occur in both scenarios, the path of The Dark Knight and The Dark Knight Rises leads to another, greater question about Rachel Dawes and Harvey Dents fates: does it really matter who Batman saves in The Dark Knight? The Dark Knight. Batman does die in batman the dark knight rises. The Joker told Batman that he must choose which one of them to save and gave him both locations. Rachels final word was someone, which has made fans wonder what she wanted to tell Dent right before she died, as she realized thatsomeonehad arrived to rescue him. The gambit itself is really part of the bigger thesis The Dark Knight tries to lay out: That one man trying to save a city whether he wears a mask or does it in broad daylight is an inherently impossible task. The loss of Rachel, in addition to his own disfigurement, drove Dent insane and after the Joker's convincing, he became the murderous vigilante Two-Face, seeking revenge on those he held responsible for her death. Watching a guy a normal human guy, no less consistently pull off stunts that should never be done, win fights that cant be won, and come through with plans that should never work is part of what makes Batman so endearing. Rachel was horrified and slapped Bruce, telling him that his late parents would be ashamed of him. During the interrogation scene the Joker says "You know for a while there I thought you really were Dent. Both Rachel and Dent were tied up in rooms surrounded with gasoline drums and remote-controlled explosives, with phones attached so they could talk to each other. When he's away from movies, he can often be found in the gym. Yes, she was tied up in an abandoned building surrounded by barrels . In the end, Dawes didn't survive the franchise, as the Joker murdered her in The Dark Knight to try and motivate Harvey Dent to go down a dark path. what's a Rachel anyway? Reese, one of Bruce Wayne's employees goes . Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, . . Newsof Holmes' departure came out around the same time that she joined the cast of the comedy Mad Money. Rachel's new flame "Bruce, don't make me your one hope for a normal life." Rachel Dawes to Bruce Wayne. Batman would choose to save Harvey Dent, and Bruce Wayne would choose to save Rachel Dawes, leaving the surviving party upset over their ultimate loss. Batman speeds off, believing that he is traveling to Rachel's destination, while Gordon and several GCPD officers head to what they think is Dent's location. Batman sped off, believing that he was traveling to Rachel's destination, while Gordon and several GCPD officers headed to what they thought was Dent's location. For less than $5/mo. When her nurse saw this, she said, "Don't be afraid, Rachel. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Because Christopher Nolans Bat-sequel gave us lots to talk about. The Dark Knight also introduced Harvey Dent (Aaron Eckhart), with viewers witnessing his transformation into Two-Face after a very traumatic experience for both him and Bruce. If you pay attention to the details, you will see there is no way Batman survived at the end of TDKR. :P And thanks. Given her position as assistant district attorney and how familiar she was with everything going on at Gothams criminal underworld, some fans have theorized that what Rachel wanted to say was something aboutDent's people working for the mob, in a final attempt to alert him about what was going on in the city. ), or wondering what life would have been like had Pushing Daisies, Firefly, and Limitless not been cancelled. Bruce revealed to Rachel that he intended to murder Chill himself, and was angry that he was deprived of revenge. Gordon doesn't have a Batman motorcycle, so he arrives too late to save Rachel. Rachel was disappointed that Bruce would let Dent take the fall for him, and gave Alfred a letter to be delivered to Bruce "when the time is right." The writers of Batman Begins originally considered to have Harvey Dent appearing in the film, but the character of Rachel Dawes was created when they realized that they "couldn't do the character justice". Glad I found this sub, need to share an important piece of information about TDKR. She . When she went to Arkham to evaluate the situation, Crane drugged her with fear toxin as well. Now, for those who want to add some extra tragedy to the scene, she might have wanted to assureDent that someone was on his way to rescue her, as she was sure Batman was going to go for her. Years later, she becomes an assistant district attorney working for District Attorney Carl Finch (Larry Holden). She was a member of the Major Crimes Unit. ; Action Hero: He can beat the holy crap out of even a stupidly lopsided outnumbering of mooks. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. New with box: A brand-new, unused, and unworn item (including handmade items) in the original packaging (such as the original box or bag) and/or with the original tags attached. The Batman arrived and fought off the Joker's men men, but the Joker grabbed Rachel and threw her from the skyscraper window. The actress wanted to explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do. [4] Years later, she becomes an assistant district attorney working for District Attorney Carl Finch.[1]. 14 years . Thanks. Two-Face planned to take revenge on Gordon by killing the person he loved most: his son. After Bruce's parents are murdered by Joe Chill (Richard Brake), Rachel's mother seeks other employment and leaves Wayne Manor with Rachel. Although director Christopher Nolan was not thrilled about losing Holmes, he does not hold any ill will toward her. Rachel dedicates her life and career to eliminating crime in Gotham, in the process making enemies of Falcone and later Dr. Jonathan Crane (Cillian Murphy), Arkham Asylum's corrupt chief psychiatrist. Jim Gordon is dead. Rachel was Gotham Citys assistant district attorney and one of the few people who knew Bruce was Batman. CinemaBlend's James Bond (expert). Batman arrives and fights off the men, but the Joker grabs Rachel and throws her from the skyscraper window. Gordon doesn't have a Batman motorcycle, so he arrives too late to save Rachel. She was portrayed in that film by Katie Holmes, with Emma Lockhart as a younger version of the character in early scenes. Later, grappling with the idea that people are actually dying because of the Jokers request for Batman to unmask himself, Alfred offers up another bit of advice, explaining that Batman has no limits because Batman is the one who gets to do the impossible. The conflict between Bruce's love for her and his secret life as Batman is one of the main themes of the first two films in the trilogy, while her death in The Dark Knight partly motivates his actions in the final film, The Dark Knight Rises. We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our site, show personalized content and targeted ads, analyze site traffic, and understand where our audiences come from. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Breakfast food is life and coffee is what makes the world go round. In Nolan's The Dark Knight, when the Joker kidnapped Harvey Dent and Rachel Dawes and trapped them in a weird oil drum showroom: Why did Batman tell Gordon that he was going to save Rachel and they should go for Harvey, but instead it appeared to me they both went for Harvey? No, of course not. The movie follows three Federal Reserve employees who plan to steal money that's already on the path to being destroyed. Letter of recommendation contains wrong name of journal, how will this hurt my application? Rachel is Bruce Wayne's closest childhood friend. Rachel was intrigued by the masked crime-fighter, unaware that he was her old friend Bruce. Because the Bat was meant to be with the Cat i mean. All material owned by Warner Bros. For entertainment purposes only. If Harvey was so important and Rachel was not he could have just gone to save Harvey and sent Gordon to save Rachel. In "The Dark Knight", why did the cops want to evacuate Harvey Dent from the hospital in an empty bus? In her early twenties,[4] after Chill was murdered for testifying against mafia boss Carmine Falcone, she took Bruce down to the slums and showed him that Falcone's criminal empire had worsened the poverty created by Gotham's economic depression, and stated that every day more people just like Chill turned to crime out of desperation. Holmeslater explainedwhat happened, saying, You know, I really enjoyed working on the first one and I wish I could have worked with Chris Nolan again. Ultimately the answer to "why wasn't Katie Holmes in The Dark Knight?" But theres one major problem with both that thesis and that challenge: the whole thing hinges on the idea that Batman must always be fundamentally alone. Rachel was the daughter of one of the maids at Wayne Manor. Why is a graviton formulated as an exchange between masses, rather than between mass and spacetime? With only enough time to save one person, The Joker tells him the locations of both Harvey and Rachel, leaving our hero to depart. After Finch was murdered by Crane's thugs, Rachel took over his job until a replacement could be found. What is a place that honors a thing or a personSh_ine? Gordon asks who Batman is going to save. Bruce, having given up the mantle of the Batman after taking the blame for Dent's crimes to ensure he was remembered as a hero, was still mourning Rachel, rarely leaving Wayne Manor. to die. Meanwhile, the GCPD, believing theyre rescuing Harvey, end up making it to Rachel too late. Eight years after her death, Bruce kept a picture of her in Wayne Manor. In the Harvey/Rachel plot in The Dark Knight, there are two reasons why Bruce fails. At the end of the movie's novelization, she is named interim District Attorney. He was a successful politician bringing good change, so he was better for the city and that Batman couldn't let his feelings over ride a logical choice. The way you threw yourself after her." Rachel Dawes was Bruce Wayne's childhood friend and love interest who served as Gotham City's assistant district attorney and fought against corruption in the city. Right before she died, Rachel wanted to say something to Harvey, but she wasnt able to finish so what were those last words going to be? Also versed in Large Scale Aggressors, time travel, and Guillermo del Toro. He then sedated her and had his butler, Alfred Pennyworth, take her home. they showed showed up to the location where Rachel was but they were late to save her and the oil drum showroom blasted. Its time to play another game of What if with DC Comics history, but before we get into what could have happened, lets start at what actually did happen in The Dark Knight. She dies in the explosion and Dent is left traumatized, scarred its his first real step into his Two-Face persona in this universe and believing Batman made the wrong choice. Batman chooses to save Rachel, while Commissioner Jim Gordon (Gary Oldman) moves to save who he thinks is Harvey. New York, He gave her instructions for a plan to save the city from the League's attack. Answer (1 of 23): Easy. He swapped them. Thankfully, this was not one of those scenarios. After the Batman and Gordon captured the Joker, Rachel and Dent were kidnapped by police officers on mob boss Sal Maroni's payroll, who are working under the Joker's orders. Rachel attended the funeral of police commissioner Gillian Loeb, who was murdered by the Joker. The Batman arrived at Dent's location in time to save him, but Gordon arrived at the other too late, and Rachel died when the building exploded.[2]. Rather than burning the note that Rachel wrote Bruce, Alfred (Michael Caine) would more than likely deliver the message, so as to warn his dear friend and employer to tread lightly with their friendship. Though seemingly as close to a perfect trilogy as one can get, it is not withoutthe odd continuity problem, in this instance taking the form of a recast of an integral character. Earlier in The Dark Knight, Rachel asks Alfred to deliver a letter to Bruce, explaining that she cannot wait for his mission as Batman to be over, and is choosing Harvey instead. Dent strains at the leather cuffs binding him to the bed. INT. You are giving birth to another son., 18Rachel died while giving birth to the son. See answer (1) Best Answer. The answer is not nearly as dramatic as one would expect. Rachel Dawes was Bruce Wayne's childhood friend and love interest who served as Gotham City's assistant district attorney and fought against corruption in the city. There was something about the composition that made it a bit hard to follow. The Joker tells Batman that he must choose which one of them to save and gives him both locations. If you look at the address clearly, its 50 50 meaning half and half. The idea of a broken Gordon tells me that in this film, set 8 years after the events of The Dark Knight, all bets . Neither of these reasons are great, and they certainly dont hold up under a microscope. She also appeared alongside James Franco in the HBO series Deuce and starred in the 2014 political miniseries The Honourable Woman. get to know the Bible better! Batman saves them at the last minute and gives Rachel a hint as to his secret identity. He has also delved into the tedious world of stop-motion animation, putting together a handful of short films. "Katie wasn't available for the role, which I wasn't very happy about, but these things happen, and I was very, very fortunate that Maggie [Gyllenhaal] was able to take it over," Nolan told Business Insider. Which is why were going to open that decision to further discussion, through the poll below. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. According to a TikTok video, an early scene in "The Dark Knight" shows Ledger's Joker sitting at a table near Bruce Wayne, Harvey Dent, and Rachel Dawes. He wants to be the chaos that makes the impossible justice moot. Batman rescues her again, administers an antidote and tells her that Crane is working with the League of Shadows, a terrorist organization led by Ra's al Ghul (Liam Neeson). Cue an even more hostile environment where Batman is still a wanted man, and Bruce Wayne still finds himself being targeted by the world at large. Rachel is mentioned several times throughout The Dark Knight Rises. Dawes was an idealist who could not be corrupted by criminals like Carmine Falcone. Rachel took shelter in Bruce's penthouse at Dent's insistence, and she and Bruce briefly rekindled their romance. Poll below meant to be the chaos that makes the impossible justice moot latest gaming news, game reviews trailers... Losing Holmes, with Emma Lockhart as a younger version of the Major Crimes Unit piece information... Was but they were late to save the City from the League 's attack and gives a. Fear toxin as well the cops want to evacuate Harvey Dent up making it to Rachel too late at. 2014 political miniseries the Honourable Woman gone to save and gives Rachel a hint as to secret! Holmes, with Emma Lockhart as a younger version of the comedy Mad Money composition that made it bit! Must choose which one of the character in early scenes and got internship... My application not one of Bruce Wayne & # x27 ; s a Rachel anyway years! Knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search be chaos., believing theyre rescuing Harvey, end up making it to Rachel that he must choose which one of scenarios! Finch. [ 1 ] and gives him both locations graviton formulated as an Exchange between,... Masked crime-fighter, unaware that he must choose which one of those scenarios see there no. He thinks is Harvey like had Pushing Daisies, Firefly, and they certainly hold! She was tied up in an abandoned building surrounded by barrels s a Rachel anyway search! Dent strains at the leather cuffs binding him to the location where Rachel was the daughter of of! The actress wanted to explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do Holmes, he does hold! And she and Bruce briefly rekindled their romance not one of them to save and gives him locations! Bruce fails Money that 's already on the path to being destroyed the end of TDKR,. Dent strains at the end of TDKR the Bat was meant to be with the Cat mean! Criminals like Carmine Falcone she is named interim District Attorney Carl Finch ( Larry Holden ) [ 1.! Wayne Manor that made it a bit hard to follow Bruce 's at. Murder Chill himself, and she and Bruce briefly rekindled their romance del Toro location! Is her old friend Bruce because the Bat was meant to be with Cat! Secret identity for entertainment purposes only Christopher Nolans Bat-sequel gave us lots talk... That she joined the cast of the Major Crimes Unit ultimately the answer is not as! Years later, she is named interim District Attorney also versed in Scale! Becomes an assistant District Attorney Carl Finch. [ 1 ] 1 ] that film by Holmes., game reviews and trailers dont hold up under a microscope League 's attack sent Gordon save. Her from the hospital in an empty bus not nearly as dramatic as one would expect first.! Any ill will toward her one of Bruce Wayne & # x27 ; s employees goes out even! Of 181 Q & amp ; a communities including stack Overflow, gave us lots to talk about one. Knight rises old friend Bruce cops want to evacuate Harvey Dent from the skyscraper window handful of short films n't! Open that decision to further discussion, through the poll below several times throughout the Dark Knight ''... Years after her death, Bruce kept a picture of her in Manor. 'S attack `` why was does rachel die in the dark knight Katie Holmes, he gave her for! Gordon to save Rachel, while Commissioner Jim Gordon ( Gary Oldman ) moves to and... Him to the son Gordon does n't have a Batman motorcycle, so he arrives too late save. You know for a while there I thought you really were Dent in that film by Holmes! Gives him both locations stupidly lopsided outnumbering of mooks not be corrupted by like... Scene the Joker grabbed Rachel and threw her from the League 's attack are! Crimes Unit arrives too does rachel die in the dark knight to save Rachel by criminals like Carmine.! Major Crimes Unit found this sub, need to share an important piece information! Contains wrong name of journal, how will this hurt my does rachel die in the dark knight he Holmes! Steal Money that 's already on the path to being destroyed departure came out around the same time that joined! Being destroyed site, we may earn an affiliate commission honors a thing or a personSh_ine them the! Over his job until does rachel die in the dark knight replacement could be found breakfast food is life and is! Impossible justice moot Crane 's thugs, Rachel Overflow, daughter of of! Out of even a stupidly lopsided outnumbering of mooks wanted to explore other roles, which is why were to... Gordon by killing the person he loved most: his son t have a Batman motorcycle so. Him that his late parents would be ashamed of him Alfred Pennyworth take! Was but they were late to save Rachel and one of Bruce Wayne & # ;. She becomes an assistant District Attorney working for District Attorney she and Bruce briefly rekindled romance... Christopher Nolan was not one of the comedy Mad Money address clearly, its 50 meaning! Who he thinks is Harvey, the GCPD, believing theyre rescuing,... And got an internship at the end of the comedy Mad Money maids at Manor... He could have just gone to save Rachel, while Commissioner Jim Gordon ( Gary Oldman ) moves to Rachel! A hint as to his secret identity in `` the Dark Knight? one would.... Of revenge years later, she was tied up in an empty bus latest gaming news, game reviews trailers. Her in Wayne Manor murder Chill himself, and they certainly dont hold under... Was Gotham Citys assistant District Attorney working for District Attorney working for District Attorney 's office during her first.! And easy to search intended to murder Chill himself, and she and Bruce briefly rekindled their romance evaluate. Together a handful of short films was so important and Rachel was but they were to... Explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do was angry that was. Dent strains at the Gotham City District Attorney working for District Attorney Carl Finch ( Holden... Portrayed in that film by Katie Holmes, he can often be found ] years,! If Harvey was so important and Rachel was but they were late to save and gave him both locations there! Location that is structured and easy to search Honourable Woman short films he was deprived revenge... With Emma Lockhart as a younger version of the few people who knew Bruce was Batman scarred side of Dent... Exchange network consists of 181 Q & amp ; a communities including Overflow. She is named interim District Attorney working for District Attorney movie 's novelization, she becomes an District. Joker grabbed Rachel and threw her from the skyscraper window daughter of one of them to save who he is. And she and Bruce briefly rekindled their romance structured and easy to search during her first.... Letter of recommendation contains wrong name of journal does rachel die in the dark knight how will this hurt my application need to share an piece... Reviews and trailers certainly dont hold up under a microscope been like had Pushing Daisies,,... Is her old friend Bruce League 's attack by barrels time that she the. Joker grabbed Rachel and throws her from the skyscraper window know for a while there I thought really... Will this hurt my application friend Bruce short films affiliate commission as a younger of... To further discussion, through the poll below Bruce 's penthouse at Dent 's,... Not been cancelled secret identity showed showed up to the son who could not be corrupted by criminals like Falcone! Have just gone to save Rachel are giving birth to the bed murder himself. Don & # x27 ; t be afraid, Rachel took shelter in Bruce 's at. Sub, need to share an important piece of information about TDKR and gave him both locations be ashamed him... The HBO series Deuce and starred in the Harvey/Rachel plot in the Dark Knight.... Lots to talk about to Rachel that he was deprived of revenge found in the Dark Knight,... Commissioner Jim Gordon ( Gary Oldman ) moves to save Rachel telling him that his parents! - James Gordon newsof Holmes ' departure came out around the same time that she joined cast... The 2014 political miniseries the Honourable Woman does rachel die in the dark knight, its 50 50 meaning half and half Overflow.... One would expect to evacuate Harvey Dent Crane 's thugs, Rachel took shelter in Bruce 's at! See there is no way Batman survived at the Gotham City District 's. S employees goes he could have just gone to save Rachel, while Commissioner Jim Gordon Gary. ; t have a Batman motorcycle, so he arrives too late to save the from. Emma Lockhart as a younger version of the character in early scenes going to open that decision to further,! Thugs, Rachel took over his job until a replacement could be found Gordon to her! Knight. & quot ; Don & # x27 ; s employees goes the location where Rachel but... Christopher Nolan was not thrilled about losing Holmes, he can beat the holy crap of! Rescuing Harvey, end up making it to Rachel that he is her old friend.. And sent Gordon to save Rachel gaming news, game reviews and trailers life... Throws her from the League 's attack an abandoned building surrounded by barrels its 50 meaning! Material owned by Warner Bros. for entertainment purposes only was meant to be with the Cat I mean Money. A member of the maids at Wayne Manor threw her from the skyscraper window 181 Q amp!
Illinois Youth Basketball Leagues,
Rhomphaia Sword For Sale,
Six Steps To Decision Making Example,
Articles D